The LearnGauge team has a track record for creating and maintaining large and complex custom learning and competency systems. Having a full appreciation for the complexity and risk involved in creating and maintaining custom systems, we are very much supportive of employing off-the-shelf systems wherever practical.
For a smaller enterprise with one division and one location that is interested in a learning system that does not necessarily need to integrate to existing systems, there are a variety of inexpensive off-the-shelf choices that will likely satisfy the needs of the organization.
For larger enterprises that may have multiple divisions, locations, languages, internal systems environments and may be a product of mergers and acquisitions, a well-conceived requirements process will reduce the risk, cost, and time to implement the system, process and culture to support and encourage continuous learning. Understanding the must-haves versus nice-to-haves is critical in the winnowing process of vendor selection.
Choosing an off-the-shelf solution will always require certain changes to the organization’s current process by which learning has been facilitated and tracked. This reality should not preclude making the choice for an off-the-shelf solution. The time, risks, and change that will be required to conform to the design of an off-the-shelf system need to be balanced against the investment in time and the risks inherent in building a custom system.